What came first in music recording?

why not define what a phonoautogram is?

I have records, 8 tracks, and cassettes, so phonotograum had to be it.

ZyggyStardust, most known as a cylinder, I think the first was made of wax.

Firegirl, my mom, an antique dealer for 40 years, had a morning Glory phonograph and the recorded canisters that went with it. shaped like Campbell's soup cans. very old collectibles.

Love Music.

wasn't it the cylinder tubes?

My parents and grandparents had recordings made on a wire, which was on a spool. It's almost impossible to find a way to play it, though. It takes equipment that doesn't seem to exist any longer.

What media was it saved on?